Everyone Gets Paid But the Family Caregiver

On October 15, Modern Healthcare ran a story with the headline “Why health systems are putting big bucks behind family caregivers.”

The article describes your work right away, in the second paragraph. Family caregivers are “vital to hospital at home, dementia care and other home-based medical programs. They provide medication management, wound care, meal preparation and other services to patients.”

Vital. Medication management. Wound care. Skilled work that the story says hospitals need in order to move care into the home.

Then the story describes who gets paid for this opportunity to delegate more work to the family caregiver. Every person and organization around the family caregiver gets reimbursed. Everyone except the family caregiver.

They need you. They just don’t want to have to reimburse you for your skilled work that makes the system work.

Follow the money

This one article lists who gets paid:

  • Atrium Health’s Levine Children’s Hospital uses part of a $1.6 million gift from The Duke Endowment for education, coaching and care coordination for families in its hospital-at-home program.

  • Maimonides Medical Center used a $95,000 grant from the John A. Hartford Foundation to hire a social worker for family caregivers.

  • Mount Sinai and the Hospital at Home Users Group, a consortium of providers and vendors, received $2.3 million from Hartford to scale hospital at home.

  • Physicians and other providers can bill CMS codes for training family caregivers.

  • GUIDE dementia care sites are paid to offer family caregivers training, education and respite.

  • Trualta, a training platform, receives a monthly fee from Hackensack Meridian Health, which Medicare reimburses. Trualta has contracts with 70 health systems and insurers in 35 states.

  • Medicare Advantage plans will add supports for family caregivers. Next year 8% of plans will offer them.

Gifts, grants, salaries, billing codes, platform fees and plan benefits. The family caregiver doing the medication management and the wound care receives none of it.

Who benefits from the work

The story is honest about why hospitals care. Khadeja Kausar of Maimonides explained it plainly: “We know established patients who have caregivers have fewer readmissions. Patients who have caregivers also have shorter lengths of stay.”

Fewer readmissions and shorter stays save hospitals money. Hackensack now checks whether its platform reduces readmissions and emergency room visits. Insurers want family caregivers who keep members out of hospitals and nursing facilities.

So the family caregiver’s work produces measurable value. The hospital counts it. The insurer counts it. The family caregiver’s bank account doesn’t change.

The 590 family caregivers who used our Non-Reimbursed Family Caregiver Savings Calculator report about 60 hours a week of this work, over about 9.7 years. Together they document more than $1 billion in lifetime value. The systems count on, and benefit from, this value.

The answer to burnout is more work

The story names the problem: the responsibility “can stress family members and put them at risk for burnout, illness or injury.”

Rani Snyder, president of the John A. Hartford Foundation, which funded the Maimonides social worker, put it this way: “[Hospital at home’s] success has to be measured by the caregiver experience as well as the patient experience. We want to ensure that families don’t experience excessive burdens during that episode of care.”

Isn’t delivering skilled work that’s designed to be non-reimbursed an excessive burden? In our Certified Caregiving Consultant training, I teach a concept called “illegitimate tasks,” which comes from Professor Norbert K. Semmer and his colleagues. The term refers to work that is either unreasonable or unnecessary. The family caregiver’s day is full of illegitimate tasks, like chasing down orders from doctors, being on hold for hours trying to resolve a billing error, and providing skilled care without a reimbursement rate.

The systems are the family caregiver’s burden. Yet, the systems decide the solution is just more training to ensure these non-reimbursed family caregivers are equipped to handle even higher acuity care the system delegates.

Their answer: Train family caregivers in hands-on skills. Educate them. Coach them through the platform.

How about reimbursing family caregivers? How about relieving them of their 24/7 workload?

We also know that family caregivers often do much more than provide care. Our calculator data shows how narrow that training focus is. About 85% of family caregivers select Emotional Support. About 58% select Personal Care. The work spans all Nine Caregiving Domains™, and most of it isn’t the hands-on skill being taught.

In my white paper released earlier this month, I talk about the emotional support I provided my dad when I completed his ostomy care. Where’s the emotional support for family caregivers who continue to do the work of the system?

Non-reimbursed by design

The word “unpaid” appears five times in the story. Each time, it simply describes the family caregiver, the way you’d describe their age or their relationship to the caree. No one in the story treats it as a problem to solve.

I can’t stop thinking about this. Every dollar in this story was a choice. A foundation chose to fund a social worker. A health system chose to pay a platform. CMS chose to create codes for training family caregivers, not for paying them. Each of those choices could have included the family caregiver. None did.

I don’t think the people in this story mean family caregivers harm. Many of them care deeply. But a system that pays everyone around the work except the person doing it isn’t an accident. It’s a design. And designs can change.

Family caregivers aren’t unpaid. We’re non-reimbursed. The money is moving through this system right now. The question is whether any of it will ever reach the person doing the work.

If you’re a family caregiver, what work are you doing that someone else is being paid to support?

Resources

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Save to list